Appendix 2. Rubric for Analytic and Holistic Evaluation in Genie Corpus (Rhee, 2016)

Levels Category Description Proficiency achievement
5 Mastery Speech speed & pause No/Minor awkwardness & errors: Native or near-native level 91%–100%
Stress & rhythm
Intonation
Segmental features
4 Advanced Speech speed & pause Some awkwardness & errors 76%–90%
Stress & rhythm
Intonation
Segmental features
3 Adequate Speech speed & pause Occasional awkwardness & errors 51%–75%
Stress & rhythm
Intonation
Segmental features
2 Developing Speech speed & pause Frequent incorrect pronunciations 31%–50%
Stress & rhythm
Intonation
Segmental features
1 Novice Speech speed & pause Many wrong pronunciation. Unintelligible, incomprehensible speech. 0%–30%
Stress & rhythm
Intonation
Segmental features