표 4. | Table 4. 실험 결과(F1-score) | Experimental result (F1-score)
특징 조합 | FS | #F | SVM | MLP |
MFCCs (baseline) | - | 13 | 53.69 | 46.52 |
MFCCs+음질 | - | 13+5 | 52.73 | 51.10 |
RFE | 13+2 | 53.31 | 48.29 |
ETC | 13+2 | 53.31 | 48.29 |
MFCCs+운율 | - | 13+20 | 59.80 | 56.14 |
RFE | 13+8 | 58.8 | 51.11 |
ETC | 13+7 | 57.51 | 50.18 |
MFCCs+발음 | - | 13+7 | 74.45 | 64.45 |
RFE | 13+3 | 73.23 | 66.56 |
ETC | 13+5 | 72.03 | 67.37 |
MFCCs+음질+운율 | - | 13+25 | 60.09 | 59.96 |
RFE | 13+11 | 58.97 | 48.19 |
ETC | 13+9 | 63.42 | 54.94 |
MFCCs+음질+발음 | - | 13+12 | 72.89 | 68.79 |
RFE | 13+6 | 76.87 | 73.85 |
ETC | 13+6 | 76.77 | 73.02 |
MFCCs+운율+발음 | - | 13+27 | 74.20 | 66.17 |
RFE | 13+12 | 76.47 | 74.91 |
ETC | 13+9 | 78.13 | 68.22 |
MFCCs+음질+운율 +발음 | - | 13+32 | 69.41 | 69.13 |
RFE | 13+14 | 77.28 | 65.51 |
ETC | 13+10 | 80.15 | 78.09 |
SVM, support vector machine; MLP, multiple layer perceptron; MFCCs, mel frequency cepstral coefficients; RFE, recursive feature elimination; ETC, extra trees classifier.