표 2. | Table 2. 수술 전과 후, 음성치료 직후의 음향학적 분석 결과 비교 | Comparison of acoustic analysis result in before surgery, after surgery and immediately after voice therapy

Before surgery After surgery Immediately after VT p-value Post-hoc
Mean SD Median Mean SD Median Mean SD Median
F0 (Hz) 182.1 20.71 189.5 169.4 18.13 169.8 179.5 15.79 180.4 .121 -
Jitter (%) .66 .52 .51 .78 .77 .58 .44 .21 .43 .202 -
Shimmer (%) 4.34 2.32 3.72 4.66 2.41 3.91 3.33 1.30 3.58 .150 -
NHR .147 .052 .133 .150 .029 .142 .130 .018 .133 .358 -
VRP (Hz) 279.9 72.8 263.4 201.3 102.0 165.8 256.6 82.0 232.2 .001 a>b*b<c*
Max VRP (Hz) 413.7 73.6 397.4 334.0 107.9 327.5 383.2 92.5 366.1 .000 a>b*b<c*
Mmin VRP (Hz) 133.8 22.2 134.6 132.6 23.0 133.6 126.6 20.9 128.6 .150 -
p<.05.
F0, fundamental frequency; NHR, noise-to-harmonics ratio; VRP, Voice Range Profile; VT, voice therapy.